Why Doesn’t Success Make Us Happy? A Conversation with Nick Stroczkowski

May 5, 2026    Nate Preisinger

What happens when you finally get everything you thought you wanted, and it still feels… empty? In this conversation, Pastor Nate sits down with longtime friend and filmmaker Nick Stroczkowski to wrestle with ambition, identity, faith, and the quiet realization that fulfillment might not be waiting somewhere in the future. Together, they explore what it means to live fully in the present, rediscover the purpose of church, and find something deeper than success.

What You’ll Learn:

Why achieving your biggest goals doesn’t guarantee fulfillment

How to tell the difference between healthy change and restless dissatisfaction

What church looks like at its best—and why it sometimes falls short

How spiritual practices help you slow down and notice what matters

Why authenticity matters more than perfection in faith and life

If this conversation resonates with you, like, subscribe, and share it with someone who might need it.

Chapters:

00:00 – Intro: When Success Doesn’t Feel Like Success

02:00 – The “Empty Box” Problem

05:30 – Why We Keep Chasing What’s Next

08:00 – Is Change Necessary or Just Restlessness?

12:00 – Don’t Mess With Happy

13:30 – Rediscovering Church in a New Season

18:00 – When Church Feels Real (and When It Doesn’t)

21:00 – Church as Product vs. Sacred Space

27:00 – What Actually Sticks After a Sermon

31:00 – Is It God or Just an Idea?

34:00 – The Problem with Being “A Good Person”

38:00 – Ego, Identity, and Wanting to Be Seen

43:00 – Vulnerability, Community, and Healing

46:30 – Why Ritual Still Matters

50:00 – The Power of Slowing Down

53:00 – Culture vs. Spiritual Practice

56:00 – Finding Balance in Real Life

57:30 – Closing Thoughts


Connect with Bethany:

📍 Bethany Lutheran Church – Denver, CO

🌐 Learn more: www.bethany-denver.org

Connect with Nick

Arclight Creative: https://arclightcreative.co/